A few years ago I was called into a large tech company. They’d launched a program and it hadn’t gone the way they wanted. Now a group of directors had to explain what happened to a key stakeholder. They knew the project well enough to run it. What they were struggling with was explaining it together.
The first thing I did was write down their entire story. Where did we start? What happened with the project? Where are we headed next? I put it in a document and gave it to them the morning of their meeting. I wanted them to read it and know it before they walked in.
Listen to what happens between speakers
The first director said a sentence. The second director picked up the next part. Then the third one continued. The day before, you could have looked at this group and wondered what they all had to do with each other. In the meeting you could hear one story all the way through. They knew where the person beside them was coming from and where the person after them needed to go.
I love that moment because if you’d asked me to identify the problem from outside the room, you might have said these people needed presentation training. But each of them already knew how to speak. What they needed was a shared account of what had happened, in an order another person could follow.
At Flavor Experience, where I told this story, you could see the same handoff in a completely different business. A chef knows where an ingredient came from and why it belongs in the dish. Marketing has to explain that choice to a customer. Somebody else has to explain it to the board. If the chef’s reason only exists in the chef’s head, every person down the line has to invent a version that makes sense to them.
For a difficult launch, I’d start with those three questions in one shared document. Have the people who were there read the account of what happened. Ask the person responsible for the next step to read the part about where you’re going. If they disagree, you’ve found something worth sorting out before the stakeholder asks. If they agree, try letting one person start the explanation and somebody else finish it. That handoff is what changed in the room I described.
That’s one use for a Confidence Document. The stakeholder gets a coherent account even when the second question goes to a different director.
About this teaching
Edited from my Flavor Experience keynote.

