From my field notes Customer experience

Why Starbucks Wanted the Smell of Its Coffee Back

In 2008, Starbucks looked at breakfast sandwiches, espresso machines and what customers actually came to a coffeehouse to experience.

I want to take you back to Starbucks in 2008.

The company had expanded enormously, and people were starting to ask some difficult questions about what the experience had become. Howard Schultz returned as CEO, and some of the decisions that followed sounded unusual for a coffee business.

One of the things he wanted to get rid of was the warmed breakfast sandwich.

Now, think about that for a moment. People liked the sandwiches. They were selling. Other chains sold breakfast sandwiches. Why would you take a successful item off the menu?

Because, according to Starbucks' own account at the time, the smell of those sandwiches was interfering with the smell of the coffee.

They were selling coffee, but what were people coming for?

When I tell this story on stage, I usually get the audience to sit with that for a second.

You've got a company trying to serve people faster, sell them more food and make the stores more efficient. Those all sound like things a business should want to do.

But the experience people were having had changed.

Schultz had also raised concerns about the large automatic espresso machines. They were efficient, but some of them stood between the barista and the customer. People couldn't see what was happening behind the counter in quite the same way.

Starbucks had spent years making coffee feel like an experience, something closer to a café you wanted to spend time in. Schultz believed parts of that experience were disappearing.

In an internal January 2008 transformation memo, Starbucks explained that warmed sandwiches would be discontinued in North America that year because their aroma competed with the coffee experience. A later memo discussed retraining baristas and introducing free Wi-Fi. The company also moved toward lower-profile espresso machines. And the sandwich story kept going. By July, Starbucks had changed ingredients, including the cheese and the butter in the eggs, to reduce the competing aroma. That detail matters to me because it tells you what they were actually trying to protect. Nation’s Restaurant News covered the recipe changes at the time.

I use a line on stage where I have Schultz tell the room to find him some really good chairs. That's my dramatization of the third-place idea, not a verified quotation from a Starbucks meeting. I want the audience to think about how comfortable the café feels and whether they want to stay.

Starbucks brought the sandwiches back

Here's another detail I think matters.

Starbucks eventually brought those breakfast sandwiches back after reworking how they were prepared. Schultz spoke about that decision later, including the need to fix the aroma problem.

So I wouldn't tell you this was a story about food being bad for the brand. The point was to pay attention to the experience people expected when they walked through the door.

In the middle of all the things a business can measure, like speed, menu sales and the number of transactions, you can lose track of something as familiar as how the place smells.

And for Starbucks, that mattered.

Which part of the café does the customer buy?

Put yourself in the position of the person evaluating the sandwich. If you look only at customers who order one, you can learn whether it sells and whether people like it. What happens to the customer who came in for a coffee and never ordered food? They still smell the sandwich. Their experience changed too, and you won’t find that in the sandwich sales.

The espresso machine raises the same question from a different direction. A faster machine can do exactly what you bought it to do while putting something between the barista and the person they’re serving. If part of what somebody comes in for is the coffee smell, being able to see a familiar face and having a reason to stay, then those details belong in the business decision alongside speed and food sales.

That’s the question I’d bring to a team considering a new feature. Who will experience the change even if they never buy the thing you added? At Starbucks, the answer included everybody who walked in and took a breath.

About this teaching

Edited from my Flavor Experience and AHFA talks. Starbucks' original sources establish the January 2008 breakfast-sandwich decision and its February 2008 transformation steps. The July reporting above documents the subsequent recipe changes. My onstage chair dialogue is a dramatization, not a transcript of a company meeting.

Chirag Nijjer

About this notebook

I'm Chirag Nijjer, The Brand Historian™.

I travel, research and collect stories about the brands that have shaped our world. I also bring those stories to stages, and you may have seen me on HISTORY Channel's The Mega Brands That Built America. These field notes start with my recordings and get edited for reading.

Learn a little more about me →

You've reached the end of this page

Now, what story are you trying to tell?

If you're planning an event, I'd love to learn who's in the room. If you're working on your own brand, bring me the question you've been struggling with.

For conferences and teams

Let's bring this to your room.

Every talk is tailored to your audience. I research your industry's history and speak with attendees before I write it.

Get the speaker packet

See what I speak about →

For business owners

Let's talk about your brand.

Have a story you're trying to make clearer? Bring it to a one-to-one session and we'll work through it together.

Schedule time with me

See the Brand Clarity Framework™ →

Chirag Speaks

Your Story Will Be Written.
Let’s Make Sure It’s By Your Pen.

Chirag@ChiragSpeaks.com >
Get the speaker packet