When Febreze first came into the world, the technology was incredibly impressive. It could remove odors from fabrics.
Good product, right? It takes away smells. Surely people would want that.
That's how I tell the story on stage. Everybody agrees that getting rid of bad smells sounds useful. But early sales weren't matching what the company expected.
So what's going on?
First, you have to convince people they have a problem
Part of the issue was that people get used to the smells in their own homes. If I'm used to a smell, I might not even know it's there. So telling me you have a spray that gets rid of it doesn't necessarily give me a reason to go buy it.
In one account of the early research, P&G visited a woman who lived with several cats. She loved her home, and she didn't think she had an odor problem. That was the issue the researchers were running into.
You could have the best odor-removing technology in the world, but what do you say to someone who doesn't recognize the problem you're offering to solve?
The company went back to watching how people cleaned their homes.
And one of the observations was remarkably simple.
Watch what happens at the end of cleaning
Think about what happens when you finish cleaning a room. You put the broom away, look around, straighten one last thing, and have that little feeling of being done.
The part I linger on when I tell this story is the doorway. The woman has finished the living room. In my telling, the broom and the other equipment are already at the edge of the door, ready for the next room. That’s when she reaches for the Febreze. The spray is how she finishes.
I find this fascinating. The product was still doing its job, but the consumer had given it a different one.
The original pitch was all about removing odors. The emerging reason to use it was that you wanted the room to smell good after you'd cleaned it.
And that changed the way Febreze was sold.
P&G brought fragrance more prominently into the formula and began showing the spray as a finishing touch to cleaning. Charles Duhigg documented the research and the relaunch in his reporting on consumer habits. The summer 1998 relaunch became a major turnaround for the product.
So there was a real product change, more perfume was added, and there was a change to the way the company explained when and why you'd reach for it. I want to be clear about both.
What happened immediately before she sprayed?
If you’re asking whether the product works, you’ll pay attention to what happens after the spray. The odor goes away. That answers the engineer’s question. Watch the few seconds before the spray and you see the broom going down, the woman looking around the room, the little pause before she moves on. That answers a different question: what tells her it’s time to pick up the bottle?
You can see why that changes the advertising. An ad about a bad smell asks the customer to identify a problem in their own home. An ad showing somebody finishing a room gives them a moment in their own day when they might reach for the spray. And if the fragrance helps the room feel finished, the formula matters to that promise as well.
If you’re trying to understand why people reach for something you make, ask to see the last part of the task they do before they use it. In this story, the interesting bit of research starts while the bottle is still sitting there untouched.
About this teaching
Edited from my Flavor Experience and AHFA keynote tellings. Historical reporting and the formula clarification are based on Charles Duhigg's account, republished by WIRED and Forbes' summary of the 1998 relaunch. The cat-owner and consumer-research anecdotes are reported historical stories, not events I personally witnessed.

